Maximize EU pollinator protection: Minimize risk

EU ministries should never lower the level of protection for bees. Doing so puts future generations at risk of living in a world without pollinators.

If you belong to the scientific community and you support this call, please sign this letter.

Read the full letter below.

Maximize EU pollinator protection: Minimize risk

490 signatures

Maximize EU pollinator protection: Minimize risk

Bees and other pollinators play vital roles in biodiversity and food security, and they are a source of income and inspiration. Yet, bees’ biodiversity and abundance are decreasing every day. Their decline, driven by pesticides (1–4), poses serious threats to the environment, ecosystems, and human health. The European pesticide authorization framework states that a pesticide can only be put on the market if it has no harmful effects on human health or animal health and no unacceptable effects on the environment (5). EU ministries met in June to decide what constitutes an “acceptable” effect of a pesticide on bees (6). Despite scientific evidence indicating that the current level of protection is barely adequate, they tentatively agreed to provide even less protection moving forward(6). We call on EU governments to apply the maximum level of protection of pollinators from pesticides. 

In 2013, the European Food Safety Authority, at the request of EU Member State governments, set a maximum acceptable level of 7% reduction on colony size (i.e., number of bees per colony) (7). Many beekeepers, environmentalists, and scientists have argued that scientific evidence shows that 7% is already too high (the only truly acceptable level would be 0%) (8). Evidence also shows that wild pollinator species are more vulnerable than honey bees to pesticides (9) and continue to rapidly decline (10–12). Disregarding the abundant evidence and the consensus of scientists, the EU ministries agreed to raise the acceptable maximum from 7 to 10% (6).  

The impact of pesticides on pollinators is vast, clear, and increasingly well documented. The EU ministries must act responsibly and make the rigorous decisions that will protect biodiversity by basing their regulatory requirements on scientific evidence. They must not accept any negative impact on honey bee colonies or other pollinators due to pesticide exposure. EU ministries should never lower the level of protection for bees. Doing so puts future generations at risk of living in a world without pollinators.

REFERENCES AND NOTES

1. E. M. Peterson, F. B. Green, P. N. Smith, Ecotoxicology and Environmental Safety. 208, 111681 (2021).

2. H. Jactel et al., Comptes Rendus. Biologies. 343, 267–293 (2021).

3. J. M. Iwasaki, K. Hogendoorn, Agriculture, Ecosystems & Environment. 314, 107423 (2021).

4. L. Drivdal, J. P. van der Sluijs, Current Opinion in Insect Science. 46, 95–105 (2021).

5. E. European Parliament, Council of the European Union, Official Journal of the European Union. L309, 1–50 (2009).

6. “Bees still at risk as EU Member States deem significant losses acceptable,” BeeLife (2021); www.bee-life.eu/post/bees-still-at-risk-as-eu-member-states-deem-significant-losses-acceptable.

7. EFSA, EFSA J. 10, 2668 (2012).

8. “Beekeeping organisations and civil society concerns on pesticide risk assessment methodology and bees’ protection from pesticides,” BeeLife (2021); www.bee-life.eu/post/civil-society-urges-the-european-council-to-secure-highest-protection-of-bees-and-pollinators).

9.  M. Arena, F. Sgolastra, Ecotoxicology 23, 324–334 (2014).

10. E. E. Zattara, M. A. Aizen, One Earth 4, 114 (2021).

11. C. A. Hallmann et al., PLOS ONE 12,, e0185809 (2017).

12. A. Nieto et al., “European red list of bees” (Luxembourg, Publication Office of the European Union, 2014).

Noa Simon-Delso, BeeLife European Beekeeping Coordination, Louvain la Neuve, Belgium.

Alexandre Aebi, Laboratoire de Biodiversité du Sol, Instituts de Biologie et d’Ethnologie, Université de Neuchâtel, Neuchâtel, Switzerland.

Gerard Arnold, Laboratoire Evolution, Génomes, Comportement, Ecologie, Centre National de la Recherche Scientifique (CNRS), Gif-sur-Yvette, France.

Jean Marc Bonmatin, Centre de Biophysique Moléculaire, CNRS, 45071 Orléans, France.

Fani Hatjina, Institute of Animal Science, Department of Apiculture, ELGO DIMITRA, Thessaloniki, Greece.

Piotr Medrzycki, 6Council for Agricultural Research and Economics, Agriculture and Environment Research Centre, Bologna, Italy.

Fabio Sgolastra, Dipartimento di Scienze e Tecnologie Agro-Alimentari, Alma Mater Studiorum Università di Bologna, Bologna, Italy.

Signatures
490 Missouri Okuneva
489 Jennings Dare
488 Hardy Bauch
487 Claudine Metz
486 Alice DuBuque
485 Ervis Mema
484 Thora Cummings
483 Marta Marquardt
482 Lennie Bashirian
481 Ramadan Rafaa
480 Somaya Ramadan
479 Francois Verheggen
478 ROBERT Céline
477 Trevor Waelchi
476 jean-françois odoux
475 Raquel Martín
474 Annelise Fontana
473 Maurice BARBE
472 François Rabasse
471 Gilles ROUX
470 Jean-louis RENARD
469 Cândida Ramos
468 THIERRY SOUDAN
467 Hugues Lortat-Jacob
466 Sylvie Delahaye
465 Jelle Devalez
464 BORIAS Eric
463 claudine courtines
462 Bruno GATHIE
461 Pascaline Brébion
460 Didier Lafitte
459 Zachary Gaudin
458 Armel Pogoda
457 Jean-Luc Réjault
456 Eric Van De Pitte
455 Gilles Hug
454 Isabelle Reymond
453 Grenier Claude
452 Tetyana Vasylkivska
451 Vincent Canova
450 Alessandro Fisogni
449 Natasha de Manincor
448 Juan Antonio Sanchez
447 Issertes Mehdi
446 charlotte chiarelli
445 Lebreton Danny
444 Vincent René Douarre
443 Theodora Petanidou
442 Marco Cantonati
441 Adara Pardo
440 Laura Bortolotti
439 Cristina Amaro Costa
438 Marta Galloni
437 Clément Henri
436 Gilles RATIA
435 Sylwia Nasłowska
434 Roland Netter
433 Regina Berjano
432 Rubén Torices
431 Paolo Fontana
430 Paolo Fanti
429 Giovanni Giorgio Bazzocchi
428 Luc Evers
427 Augusto Zanella
426 Tiziano Gomiero
425 Helena Ribeiro
424 Pires João
423 Yolanda Melero Cavero
422 Luis Navarro
421 Andreia Valente
420 Montse Bacardit
419 CARLA JOSE REGO
418 Carina Azevedo
417 Helena Guedes
416 Ana Roldán Serrano
415 Joao Miguel Correia Gonçalves Vaz
414 Andrea ocaña
413 Miguel Matos
412 marta correia
411 Cristina Seabra Ferreira
410 Ana Nunes
409 Helena Peteira
408 Denis Vasiliev
407 Catarina Siopa
406 Armando Malcata
405 Laura Mendonça
404 António Rodrigues
403 Paula Silva
402 Helena Freitas
401 António Onofre Soares
400 Cândida santos
399 Nuno Ribeiro
398 João Petronilho
397 Joao Cardoso
396 Ana Pinheira
395 Ana Rufino
394 José Grosso-Silva
393 Mercedes Sánchez-Cabrera
392 Juan Cancela
391 Tiago Parreira
390 Rafael Carvalho
389 Jorge Cassinello
388 Anna Traveset
387 Milene Matos
386 Lucie Mota
385 Teresa Abaigar
384 Alfonso Azpiazu Sanchez
383 Marta Barnadas Serinanell
382 Ainhoa Magrach
381 Priscila Gomez Polo
380 Lucía DeSoto
379 Arturo Lonighi
378 Gustavo Tomas
377 albert solé-benet
376 Dolores Ruiz-Lupión
375 Monica Gonzalez
374 Xavier Arnan
373 Soledad Mayor
372 Anders Nielsen
371 Francisco Pugnaire
370 Gabriela Doria
369 María Lourdes Moraza
368 Ruiz Martínez José
367 María Pilar Gavín Centol
366 Sílvia Castro
365 João Loureiro
364 Alba Fernández
363 David Martínez Albert
362 Ester Martínez Renau
361 Lola Parra
360 Sara Reverté
359 Marta Montserrat-Larrosa
358 Francisca Ruano
357 Carlos Hernández-Castellano
356 Christian Kindler
355 Jordi Moya-Laraño
354 Santiago Martínez Gómez
353 Ana Moreno
352 Marcos Fernández-Martínez
351 Denis Michez
350 Gloria Maria BEDOYA RENDON
349 Javiet Segovia
348 Raquel Segovia Valverde
347 Santiago Segovia
346 Scott Armbruster
345 Alejandra Bajo
344 Maria Clara Castellanos
343 Paula Sánchez Ortiz
342 Cristina Segovia
341 Chema Catarineu
340 Virginia Mielgo Gonzalez
339 Oscar Giovanni Gutiérrez Cárdenas
338 David Nogales
337 Luciana Jaime
336 Rafael Font
335 Monica Segovia
334 Rosario Morillo Pino
333 Celeste Azpiazu Segovia
332 David Garcia Callejas
331 Sergio Albacete González
330 Maria Vives-Ingla
329 Anselm Rodrigo Domínguez
328 Arnald Marcer
327 Joan Llusià
326 Mª Ángeles García
325 Annelies Broekman
324 Cátia Martins
323 Ivette Serral
322 Anabel Sanchez
321 Laura Roquer Beni
320 Narcís Vicens
319 Nora Pastor
318 Marcos Miñarro
317 Jordi Bosch
316 Beti PIOTTO
315 Chensheng Lu
314 Juan Santiago
313 Максим Черник
312 Huoqing Zheng
311 zhaonan zhang
310 Shenpu ZHANG
309 Marion Zammit Mangion
308 Johann Zaller
307 Lai Yuan
306 Liudmyla Yazlovytska
305 Ibrahim Yasser
304 Venkatesh Y N
303 Fotios Xystrakis
302 Tiangang XU
301 GAVRIIL XANTHOPOULOS
300 Antoine wystrach
299 Abebe Jenberie Wubie
298 Piet Wit
297 Penelope Whitehorn
296 Sonja Wedmann
295 Walellign Wotro Wanore
294 Elizabeth M. Walsh
293 Julia Walochnik
292 Marianne Volleth
291 Roman Volkov
290 Jonathan Vogel
289 Dimitrios Vlachostergios
288 Irina Vivchar
287 Ramanuj Vishwakarma
286 Sandra Vincent
285 Miguel Vilas-Boas
284 Patricio Vásquez Quitral
283 Antonina Vasicka
282 kiki varikou
281 Julien Vallon
280 Dirk-Jan Valkenburg
279 Pegah Valizadeh
278 Aleksandar Uzunov
277 Camila Uribe
276 Amjad Ullah
275 Emmanuel Tzortzakakis
274 Yurij Tynkevich
273 Lesia Tymochko
272 Makrina Tsinoglou
271 Agazhe Tsegaye
270 Simone Tosi
269 Guy Thompson
268 Teklu Teklu Bira Beyene
267 Andrea Tapparo
266 Thierry TAMIC
265 gholamhosein Tahmasbi
264 George Symeon
263 Vera Strogolova
262 Verena Strobl
261 Lars Straub
260 Vasileios Stournaras
259 Martin Staron
258 Ljubiša Stanisavljević
257 Gavriil Spyroglou
256 Robert N Spooner-Hart
255 Aleksandra Splitt
254 Paula Souto
253 Mirosława Skupińska
252 Suzana Skerbiš
251 Noa Simon Delso
250 Awraris Getachew Shenkute
249 Muhammad Zahid Sharif
248 Matt Shardlow MPhil
247 Hatem Sharaf El-Din
246 Fabio Sgolastra
245 Tetiana Senchuk
244 Rya Seltzer
243 Sebastian Schwarz
242 Janine Melanie Schwarz
241 Daniel Schläppi
240 Aygün Schiesser
239 Marc Schäfer
238 Alejandra Carla Scannapieco
237 Argyrios Sapounidis
236 VIOLETA SANTRAC
235 Malcolm Sanford
234 Delka Salkova
233 Saliha SALEM ATTIA
232 Anton Safer
231 Joana S. Amaral
230 Michael Rubinigg
229 Alice ROUZES
228 Steve Rogenstein
227 Jaime Iván Rodríguez-Fernández
226 Ulrike Riessberger-Gallé
225 Luciano Ricchiuti
224 Andreas Reichart
223 Maria Teresa Rebelo
222 Aleksandra Raczyńska
221 Andreia Quaresma
220 Zlatko Puškadija
219 Dorian Pritchard
218 Giovanni Prete
217 MARTÍN PORRINI
216 Claudio Porrini
215 Marco Porporato
214 Vladimir Polaček
213 Lennard Pisa
212 M. Alice Pinto
211 Robert Paxton
210 Ivan Pavlovic
209 Solenn Patalano
208 Evangelos Papas
207 Irina Panchuk
206 Anusree Padmanabhan P S
205 Francisco Padilla
204 Christian Pacteau
203 Melissa Oddie
202 Darren O'Connell
201 Fetnassi Nidal
200 Beatrice T. Nganso
199 Zabihollah Nemati
198 Mahdi Nazemnia
197 Anabela Nave
196 Pantelis Natskoulis
195 Georgina Mwansat
194 Mustafa Necati Muz
193 Dilek Muz
192 António Murilhas
191 Elliud Muli
190 Hugues Mouret
189 Chinelo Favour Morah
188 Coline Monchanin
187 Giulia Molinatto
186 Suman Mishra
185 Admassu Merti
184 Piotr Medrzycki
183 John McLean
182 Samantha McIntyre
181 Corina Maurer
180 Wystrach Matthias
179 Susanne Matschullies
178 Denise Margaret Matias
177 Patrice MARCHAND
176 Kannan MANI
175 Eric Malcolm
174 Valeria Malagnini
173 Jakkrawut Maitip
172 Stefano Maini
171 Siobhan Maderson
170 Chensheng (Alex) Lu
169 Susan Lorrimer
168 Ana R. Lopes
167 Olha Lisohurska
166 Dina Lisohurska
165 Simone Lioy
164 Christina Ligda
163 Sigrid Liede-Schumann
162 Mar Leza Salord
161 Vilde Leipart
160 Yves Le Conte
159 Abdrahaman Adebowale Lawal
158 H. Michael G. Lattorff
157 Martin Kunz
156 Mert Kükrer
155 Nikos Krigas
154 Panagiotis Koulelis
153 Sergej Komisarenko
152 Andre Koch
151 Tristan Kistler
150 Fiona Kinniburgh
149 Kira Khamid
148 Peter Kevan
147 Victor Kavvadias
146 Nektarios Kavroulakis
145 Volodymyr Karavan
144 İrfan Kandemir
143 Pierre Kamtsap
142 Martin Kampel
141 Elisabeth Kampel
140 Mohamed Kaandeil
139 Chuleui Jung
138 George Japoshvili
137 Jacek Jachuła
136 Olha Ishchenko
135 Chama Inson
134 Mohammed Ibrahim Mustafa
133 Laurence Huc
132 Thomas Hübener
131 Shaokang Huang
130 Thomas Hörnschemeyer
129 Kibebew Hora
128 Borja Heredia
127 Gordana Hegic
126 Maria Haws
125 Louis Hautier
124 Fani Hatjina
123 Awad Hassan
122 Alen Hamzic
121 Mohamed Hammida
120 Kerealem Ejigu Haile
119 Albrecht Haase
118 Isabel Guillaume
117 Emilio Guerrieri
116 Ekaterini Grigoriadou
115 Dave Goulson
114 Joana Godinho
113 Gordana Glavan
112 Martin Giurfa
111 Ahmet Onur Girisgin
110 Tugrul Giray
109 MANUELA GIOVANETTI
108 Hervé Giffard
107 Eleni Giannopoulou
106 Alessandra Giacomelli
105 Agostina Giacobino
104 Sherly George
103 Tolera Gemeda
102 Alemayehu Gela
101 Tilahun Gebey
100 Enrico Gavagnin
99 Ioannis Ganopoulos
98 Anastasios Galanis
97 Nitin Gaikwad
96 Pries Frens
95 Mariangela Fotelli
94 Mohammad Forsi
93 Adrian Fisher II
92 Johann Fischer
91 Miriam Filipova
90 Elisabete Figueiredo
89 María Amparo Ferreira-Golpe
88 Xesùs Feàs
87 Elsa Faugère
86 Soraia Falcão
85 Michael Eyer
84 Garth Evans
83 Omar Er-Rguibi
82 Omar Er-Rguibi
81 Laghzaoui El-Mustapha
80 Hassan el mouden
79 Asmaa Eissa
78 Yoko L. Dupont
77 Usman Dukku
76 Adna Suelen Dorigo
75 Martin Dohrmann
74 Nataliia Didenko
73 Gennaro Di Prisco
72 Kedar Devkota
71 Jean-Marc DEVAUD
70 Jiří Danihlík
69 Natalia Damiani
68 Anne Dalmon
67 Bjørn Dahle
66 Paul Cross
65 Cristina Amaro da Costa
64 Marc-Edouard Colin
63 Karstens Christian
62 Nikos Chorianopoulos
61 Volodymyr Cherevatov
60 Alexandr Cherevatov
59 Eliza Cauia
58 Rafael Carvalho
57 David Carlson
56 Luca Carisio
55 Nuno Capela
54 MARIA CRISTINA CABRERA
53 Inna Buzduga
52 Jutta Buschbom
51 Eve Bureau-Point
50 Christophe Brod
49 Pierre Brawand
48 Manuela Branco
47 Nohad Boujaoude
46 Jean-Marc Bonmatin
45 Humberto Boncristiani
44 Michel BOCQUET
43 Andrzej Bober
42 Maarten Bijleveld van lexmond
41 Małgorzata Bieńkowska
40 Amssalu Bezabeh
39 Rolf Georg Beutel
38 Laura Bester
37 Suzan Benedick
36 Tura Bareke
35 Prakhya Balakrishnamurthy
34 Miguel Azevedo
33 Dimitrios Avtzis
32 Aurore Avarguès-Weber
31 Christos Astaras
30 Muhammad Asif Aziz Asif
29 Gérard ARNOLD
28 Rajini Arjun
27 George Arampatzis
26 Alireza Arab
25 Mohamed Aourir
24 Fernanda Antunes Carvalho
23 Syed Ishtiaq Anjum
22 Sergio Angeli
21 Gianfranco Anfora
20 Mohammad Alqurneh
19 Fabrice Allier
18 Dr. Dalal M. Aljedani
17 Shahzad Ali
16 Mudssar Ali
15 Cedric Alaux
14 Yahya Al Naggar
13 Amro Ahmed Taha
12 Ahmed abdelkaway Ahmed abdelaal
11 Aggrey Agaba
10 Alexander Aebi
9 Popoola Joseph Adekola
8 Leonora Adamchuk
7 Aglagane Abdessamad
6 Tarek Abdelrahman
5 Aida Abd El-Wahed
4 Mohammed Getahun Abate
3 Emmet Watsica
2 Verna Roberts
1 Noa Simon